| Name | Mat | vs | Venue | Date | |||
| 1 | ![]() | W Rhodes | 52y 156d | 58 | WIN
| Kingston | 3 Apr 1930 |
| 2 | ![]() | H Ironmonger | 50y 322d | 14 | ENG
| Sydney | 23 Feb 1933 |
| 3 | ![]() | WG Grace | 50y 318d | 22 | AUS
| Nottingham | 1 Jun 1899 |
| 4 | ![]() | G Gunn | 50y 294d | 15 | WIN
| Kingston | 3 Apr 1930 |
| 5 | ![]() | J Southerton | 49y 135d | 2 | AUS
| Melbourne | 31 Mar 1877 |
| 6 | ![]() | Miran Bakhsh | 47y 299d | 2 | IND
| Peshawar CG | 13 Feb 1955 |
| 7 | ![]() | JB Hobbs | 47y 243d | 61 | AUS
| The Oval | 16 Aug 1930 |
| 8 | ![]() | FE Woolley | 47y 83d | 64 | AUS
| The Oval | 18 Aug 1934 |
| 9 | ![]() | DD Blackie | 46y 302d | 3 | ENG
| Adelaide | 1 Feb 1929 |
| 10 | ![]() | H Strudwick | 46y 198d | 28 | AUS
| The Oval | 14 Aug 1926 |
| 11 | ![]() | EH Hendren | 46y 37d | 51 | WIN
| Kingston | 14 Mar 1935 |
| 12 | ![]() | AJ Traicos | 45y 300d | 7 | IND
| Delhi | 13 Mar 1993 |
| 13 | ![]() | GOB Allen | 45y 240d | 25 | WIN
| Kingston | 27 Mar 1948 |
| 14 | ![]() | P Holmes | 45y 213d | 7 | IND
| Lord's | 25 Jun 1932 |
| 15 | ![]() | AW Nourse | 45y 204d | 45 | ENG
| The Oval | 16 Aug 1924 |
| 16 | ![]() | DB Close | 45y 135d | 22 | WIN
| Manchester | 8 Jul 1976 |
| 17 | ![]() | EG Wynyard | 44y 339d | 3 | RSA
| Johannesburg OW | 6 Mar 1906 |
| 18 | ![]() | JMM Commaille | 44y 313d | 12 | ENG
| Cape Town | 31 Dec 1927 |
| 19 | ![]() | R Abel | 44y 236d | 13 | AUS
| Manchester | 24 Jul 1902 |
| 20 | ![]() | GA Headley | 44y 230d | 22 | ENG
| Kingston | 15 Jan 1954 |
| 21 | ![]() | Amir Elahi | 44y 102d | 6 | IND
| Kolkata | 12 Dec 1952 |
| 22 | ![]() | CV Grimmett | 44y 65d | 37 | RSA
| Durban | 28 Feb 1936 |
| 23 | ![]() | WR Hammond | 43y 275d | 85 | NZL
| Christchurch LP | 21 Mar 1947 |
| 24 | ![]() | H Carter | 43y 256d | 28 | RSA
| Cape Town | 26 Nov 1921 |
| 25 | ![]() | W Bardsley | 43y 251d | 41 | ENG
| The Oval | 14 Aug 1926 |
| 26 | ![]() | CP Carter | 43y 115d | 10 | ENG
| The Oval | 16 Aug 1924 |
| 27 | ![]() | Misbah-ul-Haq | 42y 347d | 75 | WIN
| Roseau | 10 May 2017 |
| 28 | ![]() | JE Emburey | 42y 341d | 64 | WIN
| Manchester | 27 Jul 1995 |
| 29 | ![]() | HW Taylor | 42y 298d | 42 | NZL
| Christchurch LP | 27 Feb 1932 |
| 30 | ![]() | WW Whysall | 42y 289d | 4 | AUS
| The Oval | 16 Aug 1930 |
| 31 | ![]() | AFA Lilley | 42y 254d | 35 | AUS
| The Oval | 9 Aug 1909 |
| 32 | ![]() | RW Taylor | 42y 246d | 57 | PAK
| Lahore | 19 Mar 1984 |
| 33 | ![]() | N Betancourt | 42y 242d | 1 | ENG
| Port-of-Spain | 1 Feb 1930 |
| 34 | ![]() | C Kelleway | 42y 219d | 26 | ENG
| Brisbane EG | 30 Nov 1928 |
| 35 | ![]() | GA Faulkner | 42y 194d | 25 | ENG
| Lord's | 28 Jun 1924 |
| 36 | ![]() | FR Brown | 42y 191d | 22 | AUS
| Lord's | 25 Jun 1953 |
| 37 | ![]() | WAS Oldfield | 42y 170d | 54 | ENG
| Melbourne | 26 Feb 1937 |
| 38 | ![]() | SE Gregory | 42y 127d | 58 | ENG
| The Oval | 19 Aug 1912 |
| 39 | ![]() | JWHT Douglas | 42y 120d | 23 | AUS
| Melbourne | 1 Jan 1925 |
| 40 | ![]() | NE Haig | 42y 112d | 5 | WIN
| Kingston | 3 Apr 1930 |
| 41 | ![]() | H Elliott | 42y 100d | 4 | IND
| Chennai | 10 Feb 1934 |
| 42 | ![]() | RB Simpson | 42y 84d | 62 | WIN
| Kingston | 28 Apr 1978 |
| 43 | ![]() | WW Armstrong | 42y 83d | 50 | ENG
| The Oval | 13 Aug 1921 |
| 44 | ![]() | DS de Silva | 42y 73d | 12 | ENG
| Lord's | 23 Aug 1984 |
| 45 | ![]() | FJ Titmus | 42y 62d | 53 | AUS
| Adelaide | 25 Jan 1975 |
| 46 | ![]() | MC Cowdrey | 42y 46d | 114 | AUS
| Melbourne | 8 Feb 1975 |
| 47 | ![]() | WE Astill | 42y 33d | 9 | WIN
| Kingston | 3 Apr 1930 |
| 48 | ![]() | EAB Rowan | 42y 27d | 26 | ENG
| The Oval | 16 Aug 1951 |
| 49 | ![]() | SJ Snooke | 42y 15d | 26 | ENG
| Durban | 16 Feb 1923 |
| 50 | ![]() | TW Graveney | 41y 361d | 79 | WIN
| Manchester | 12 Jun 1969 |
Mat = Number of matches played in career.
Date column and player's age correspond to first day of match.